That is according to former Toffees boss Sam Allardyce, who says Liverpool star Andy Robertson evaded his old club’s grasp too.
Maguire joined Leicester from Hull last June in a deal worth £17m and has since established himself as an England international.
The 25-year-old played a key role as the Three Lions reached the World Cup semi-finals this summer and that attracted interest from Manchester United.
Maguire’s fortunes contrast markedly to those of Michael Keane, who has been capped by England and left Burnley for Everton 12 months ago.
Keane’s stock has fallen since his switch to Goodison Park and he faces being shunted down the pecking order by Yerry Mina and potentially Kurt Zouma’s arrivals on Merseyside.
Allardyce has now claimed Everton could have snapped up Maguire around the same time Ronald Koeman bought Keane from Burnley.
And he’s revealed Robertson, who’s gone on to thrive at rivals Liverpool, could have been part of a double-deal with Hull too.
“[Everton] were [close to getting Maguire]… I was told by Steve Walsh, who was the director of football when I got there that that was a very big opportunity for them to take Maguire and, [Walsh] said, Robertson,” Allardyce told talkSPORT.
“Both from Hull City, what a pair they would have been.
“That’s what I’m talking about recruitment, Alan [Brazil], you can ill-afford any slip-ups.”
TalkSPORT host Alan Brazil offered his own take on the revelation Allardyce made on Thursday morning.
“Maguire and Robertson, oh dear,” said Brazil.
“Evertonians, I hope I’ve not spoilt your breakfast.”
Meanwhile, Everton are yet to announce the capture of Mina from Barcelona.
However, Barcelona say Mina has joined Everton on a permanent deal worth £27.2m (€30.25m), plus £1.35m (€1.5m) in bonuses.
Barcelona have inserted a buy-back clause into the agreement for the centre-back, who shone like Maguire at this summer’s World Cup.
Barcelona have also confirmed Andre Gomes’ loan to Everton, with Marco Silva’s side stumping up £2m (€2.25m) for the deal and agreeing to pay his wages for the duration of the 2018/19 campaign.
Mina and Gomes join Bernard, Richarlison and Lucas Digne in putting pen to paper at Everton, while Chelsea’s Zouma could seal a loan switch with a deal sheet lodged with the Premier League.
Richarlison (Watford) Undisclosed
Lucas Digne (Barcelona) Undisclosed
Joao Virginia (Arsenal) Undisclosed
Bernard (Shakhtar Donetsk) Undisclosed
Yerry Mina (Barcelona) £27.2m
Andre Gomes (Barcelona) loan
Joel Robles (Real Betis) Free
Jose Baxter (released)
David Henen (released)
Ramiro Funes Mori (Villarreal) Undisclosed
Wayne Rooney (D.C. United) Undisclosed
Luke Garbutt (Oxford United) Loan
Henry Onyekuru (Galatasaray) Loan
Shani Tarashaj (Grasshopper Club Zurich) Loan
Davy Klaassen (Werder Bremen) Undisclosed
Ashley Williams (Stoke City) Loan
Antonee Robinson (Wigan) Loan
Kevin Mirallas (Fiorentina) Loan
Callum Connolly (Wigan Athletic) Loan
Read more here: Daily Express :: Sport Feedhappy wheels
Oct 12, 2018 0Dolled up with a silvery white wig, snow-white cable knit Fashion Nova two piece set and furry pink slides, reality star-turned-femcee Tabatha Robinson contrasted the dreary outside forecast in every way. She entered the room, propped herself on a jaded grey chair to put the final touches on her...
Oct 11, 2018 0
Oct 22, 2018 0Filmmakers David Gordon Green and Danny McBride came onto Halloween as super fans of the franchise, eager to continue what John Carpenter started and expand on it with their own signature. The setback of not having enough time, or money, initially, to make the opening scene they set out to was...
Oct 22, 2018 0
Oct 20, 2018 0It’s normal for frown lines to get deeper and more...
Oct 19, 2018 0The Shills Acne Purifying Peel-Off Black Mask ($ 11;...
Oct 19, 2018 0Let’s be real, we know blondes don’t actually have more...
Oct 22, 2018 0DUBAI, United Arab Emirates — Marooned outside South...
Oct 22, 2018 0BRUSSELS — The trade group Safer Phosphates would seem to...
Oct 22, 2018 0JERUSALEM — Treasury Secretary Steven Mnuchin on Sunday...
Oct 22, 2018 0Turkish officials have been leaking lurid details for weeks...
Oct 22, 2018 0The Sagrada Familia basilica in Barcelona has worldwide...
Oct 21, 2018 0NEW DELHI — They were watching the bad guy go down. On a...
Oct 21, 2018 0CIUDAD TECÚN UMÁN, Guatemala — Members of a caravan of...
Oct 21, 2018 0MOUNT ATHOS, Greece — The skulls, lined up five deep on...
Oct 21, 2018 0KABUL, Afghanistan — Voting under threat of Taliban...
Oct 21, 2018 0[Sign up for the Australia Letter to get news, conversation...